Conversion: Denied

In all the time I spent studying to convert to Orthodox Judaism, nothing about vaccines ever came up in conversation.

However, on account of a recent measles outbreak, every school has made a rule that children who are unvaccinated may not go to yeshiva any more.

My conversion is on account of a mistake in earlier life. Our family converted Conservative, and I have been living as a religious Jew for all of my adult life. But now we want to dot our "i"s and cross the "t"s as they say.

Why don't I vaccinate? Because of an injury I had, from a vaccine, when I was in college. 

Anyway, the rabbi asked me if I was committed to sending my kids to Jewish day school? Of course I am! But my kids are currently not welcome in school.  

Stupidly, I noted that we'd love to send our kids to school. But they are denied access on account of our stance.

Conversion status: Denied.

This is Orthodox Judaism? Making up new rules as we go along? I'm not sure I want in any more.

Since when is a stance on vaccination grounds for being allowed in or allowed out of the Jewish community?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Differences Shouldn't Tear Us Apart

We've been saying this a very long time. We need to live together and stop tearing apart from one another over health and medical choices. People are not wired the same. But we all live in the same world.  It's time we recognized that.  Good job, Chofetz Chaim Heritage Foundation!
Read more

There is only one kind of TRUE HERD Immunity

It comes from getting the disease naturally and creating a real immunity. Vaccine immunity wanes, requires boosters all the time, and is not guaranteed. Why does the government say anyone born before 1957 doesn't need shots? Because they were assumed to have been exposed to the real, wild virus, and has lifelong immunity. That's the real herd immunity for infectious diseases. And within a few decades it will be dying off. Thank God for those who have gotten measles naturally in the last few years. They're our only hope.
Read more

A Doctor

Just found this: To be honest (see how we are not afraid to show the other side), here is an article that takes Dr. Meehan to task . The top argument Skeptical Raptor uses is questioning assumed "authority." Without having a "degree" in vaccinology, Dr. Meehan is not allowed to formulate an opinion. (The thousands of studies around the world that are referenced mostly compare fully vaccinated to those who are partially vaccinated - never to the completely unvaccinated. Since the incidence of reactions between the vaccinated PLUS MMR and the vaccinated MINUS MMR are statistically similar, the vaccine being "studied" is deemed safe. Their longer-term effects are not included in these studies, which watch for reactions for a very limited amount of time.) With that argument, Rav Asher Weiss's opinion is also invalid . Having a degree does not confer more wisdom. It all depends on how much a person studies - whether in an educational setting or as an
Read more